BATTING: Revisiting 2011 overperformers

Back before the season started, the BBG looked at batters who seemed to have had “lucky” HR and BA performance in 2011 that made them gambles for 2012.

In every case but one, we advised caution in bidding or drafting these players to full 2011 value.

In this edition we’ll look back to see if that advice turned out to be sound, and comment on the whole idea of recency bias in player valuation.

Review: Methods

Our method was fairly simple: We found every 2011 batter whose fantasy value increased more than $15 over 2010 (batters with negative 2010 value were reset to zero dollars), and then found batters whose HRs and BA stats seemed to have benefited from unusual luck—uncharacteristically high HR per outfield flyball rate...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Batters

Geraldo Perdomo has developed into one of the most impressive young bats in the game, and there's more growth to come.
Jun 30 2025 3:05am
Fantasy impacts with three teams using a new leadoff hitter, though the new third batter for St. Louis may be the biggest beneficiary of the lineup changes.
FREE
Jun 27 2025 3:10am
Juan Soto's up-and-down first half can be traced back to some significant struggles hitting with runners on base.
Jun 23 2025 3:06am
Josh Naylor's bat-to-ball acumen and exit velocity merge as a potent force when he hits at home.
Jun 16 2025 3:05am
Today's post explores a TOR and a TEX hitter each moving up in the batting order, thereby enhancing their value. Plus, a rookie catcher has been hitting cleanup for BOS.
Jun 13 2025 3:06am

Tools