BATTING: Revisiting 2011 overperformers

Back before the season started, the BBG looked at batters who seemed to have had “lucky” HR and BA performance in 2011 that made them gambles for 2012.

In every case but one, we advised caution in bidding or drafting these players to full 2011 value.

In this edition we’ll look back to see if that advice turned out to be sound, and comment on the whole idea of recency bias in player valuation.

Review: Methods

Our method was fairly simple: We found every 2011 batter whose fantasy value increased more than $15 over 2010 (batters with negative 2010 value were reset to zero dollars), and then found batters whose HRs and BA stats seemed to have benefited from unusual luck—uncharacteristically high HR per outfield flyball rate...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Batters

Brenton Doyle's recent surge and elite results and skills vs. LHers confirm that he has not reached his ceiling yet.
Aug 25 2025 3:07am
Following the trade deadline, Arizona has returned Geraldo Perdomo to the top of the lineup. Plus, notes on Noelvi Marte and Brett Baty deserving better spots in the batting order.
Aug 22 2025 3:10am
Two NL East outfielders, Brandon Marsh and Michael Harris II, have made notable adjustments in the course of the 2025 season.
Aug 19 2025 3:07am
Brett Baty's recent surge and wide home/road splits support his potential for even further growth.
Aug 18 2025 3:09am
Dillon Dingler's massive underlying gains since July 1 confirm he still carries significant untapped upside.
Aug 11 2025 3:05am

Tools