PT TOMORROW: AL East — Which TOR catcher is the better bet?

Toronto Blue Jays

An interesting buy-low, sell-high situation exists with the Blue Jays’ young catching tandem of Reese McGuire (C, TOR) and Danny Jansen (C, TOR).

McGuire is the left-handed hitter and finished the season on a high note, posting a .299/.346/.526 line with 5 HR in 97 AB.

The right-handed-hitting Jansen, meanwhile, rebounded slightly after a rough first half but barely dragged his batting average above the Mendoza line, but only barely.

So, they form a natural platoon, with McGuire taking the larger role, right?

“Not so fast,” as college football announcer Lee Corso might say.

For one thing, Jansen has made harder contact, and while McGuire made more frequent contact, it was by a small margin.

As discussed in the Baseball...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From PT Tomorrow

This week, we say "hello" to yet another San Diego catcher, welcome another catcher back to L.A., try to read the playing time tea leaves in Arizona and Colorado, and check in on two Giants' rookies who are playing at a high level.
Sep 5 2026 3:06am
Maikel Garcia's injury has opened up some playing time in KC, with a quartet of players who might take advantage. Plus, a new position for a CHW prospect and a look around the division.
Sep 3 2026 3:05am
Ben Joyce has been locked in as the Angels closer of late, but who's next if some control issues linger for Joyce?
Sep 2 2026 3:07am
Trevor Story is expected to be Boston's primary shortstop upon his return from the IL, but could his opportunity be short-lived if his season-long struggles continue? Plus, a potential SB source in TB, SP in BAL/BOS, and a post-hype prospect making waves for NYY.
Sep 1 2026 3:05am

Tools