FACTS/FLUKES: Donaldson, J. Montgomery, Dahl, J. Romano, W. Castro

Donaldson a more risky play with age ... The 2019 season proved to be quite productive for Josh Donaldson (3B, MIN), as he amassed 37 HR, 96 R and 94 RBI in route to a $20 season. Unfortunately, 2020 didn't go as swimmingly. A right calf injury sidelined him for nearly a month, and when it was all said and done, the 35-year-old posted 6 HR in 102 PA; netting $4 in R$. The 2021 Baseball Forecaster tagged Donaldson with a "D" Health rating, and age isn't on his side; but with an ADP (per NFBC) just inside the Top-200, has the hesitancy gone too far? 

Year PA   BA/xBA   HR/xHR ct% bb% h%  HctX GB/LD/FB HR/F/xHR/F Brl% PX/xPX  QBaB
==== === ========= ====== === === === ==== ======== ========== ==== ======= ====
2016 700 .284/.289  37/42 79%...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Facts & Flukes

Can Josh Lowe fulfill his speed/power potential in Anaheim? Plus Dillon Dingler, Griffin Jax, Matt Wallner and Nathan Eovaldi.
Mar 9 2026 3:06am
Jackson Chourio has been remarkably consistent—were there any signs of growth in his 2025 skills? Plus, Royce Lewis, Emmet Sheehan, Heliot Ramos, and Justin Sterner.
Mar 8 2026 3:06am
Coming off a breakout 2025 season, is Shea Langeliers among the catcher elite? Plus looks at Sonny Gray, Jose Altuve, José Soriano and Randy Arozarena.
Mar 5 2026 3:05am
Will Smith offers stable production at catcher. Also, dives into Nick Pivetta, Ezequiel Tovar, Pete Fairbanks and Mickey Moniak.
Mar 3 2026 3:10am
Ben Rice is coming off a big year and is a high upside option at catcher in 2025. Plus, Wilyer Abreu, Nolan Schanuel, Logan Gilbert, and Jack Leiter.
Mar 2 2026 3:08am

Tools