GM's OFFICE: Evaluating our 2017 process

When he was running BaseballHQ.com, one of Ron Shandler's annual season-ending columns was "When good projections go bad," an annual exercise that served as a warts-and-all look at the hits and misses between our pre-season projections and actual results. He would run the lists here on the site each fall, and it also appears in the Encyclopedia section of the Baseball Forecaster. (Timely reminder: the 2018 edition is available for pre-order now!)

In recent years, Brent and I have taken over the compilation of this list from Ron. But we had a bit of a communications snafu in the Forecaster production process this week, where I went off to conduct this exercise, and found that Ron had already done it for me!

So, with a hat tip to our...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From GM's Office

The 2025 fantasy baseball season is over, but once again, BaseballHQ.com writers fared quite well in industry and expert competitions. Here's the details.
Sep 30 2025 10:09am
Our annual sorting exercise for 2025's outlying performances, the first step in trying to refine our processes for 2026.
Sep 29 2025 3:03am
We get a lot of questions about the accuracy of our Starting Pitcher Matchup Scores tool. So we spent the All-Star Break conducting a validation of the scores we posted in the first half of the season. Results inside...
FREE
Jul 18 2025 3:04am
Like a certain top prospect, here are some shiny new site improvements meant to make your visit here better ...
Jun 12 2025 3:06am
Casey Mize was often an early-season lineup shifter in Matchup scores experiment. Where does it stand roughly one-third of the way through the season?
Jun 6 2025 3:08am

Tools