PLAYING TIME: Looking at AL East fifth-starter battles

AMERICAN LEAGUE

Niemann pulling ahead of Wade Davis?

With phenom Matt Moore (LHP, TAM) presumed to have a rotation spot locked up, one slot remains for relative veterans Jeff Niemann (RHP, TAM) or Wade Davis (RHP, TAM). While Davis made clear earlier this spring that he would not exactly welcome being moved to the bullpen, he didn't help his cause with a sub-par outing March 10 (2 2/3 IP, 4 R, 2 ER, 3 H, 4 BB, 2 K). How do these two pitchers' larger body of work stack up?

2011     xERA    G/L/F   Ctl  Dom  Cmd  HR/9  BPV  DOM/DIS
=======  ====  ========  ===  ===  ===  ===   ===  =======
Davis	 4.67  36/21/43  3.1  5.1  1.7  1.1    23   38/21
Niemann  3.61  46/20/34  2.5  7.0  2.8  1.2    83   61/30

Davis' protestations and...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From PT Today

The Dodgers once again flex their muscle in nabbing the top pitcher on the trade market. Plus PT ripples across the league with Luis Castillo, Lane Thomas and a slew of others changing teams.
Aug 2 2026 8:41am
Corey Seager returned from the IL and takes his place at SS for Texas. Plus another pitching add for Minnesota, and Painter and McLain get another shot to discover their upside.
Aug 1 2026 9:20am
Detroit starts making some moves and Minnesota fortifies its bullpen, all as we wait on the trade deadline deluge...
Jul 31 2026 7:25am
Edwin Díaz was activated from the IL, which changes the closer landscape for the final two months. Plus Pasquantino and Buxton return to the IL, a breakdown of the Rangers/Angels trade, and more.
Jul 30 2026 9:04am
The Red Sox scramble to adjust to Curtis Mead's broken wrist; as do the Giants with Casey Schmitt. Also the PT effects of the Javier Báez and Kiké Hernández returns.
Jul 29 2026 9:08am

Tools