Gambles, 2025
Mar 8 2025
Most starting pitchers can be considered gambles in one form or another. Some are gambles worth taking. Others should be avoided.
Here, we will discuss gambles to avoid and define them as SP who are likely to be significantly overvalued on draft day.
This doesn't mean you should avoid targeting all of the guys listed here, but it does mean that you should think twice before bidding full value on them.
Here is a closer look at 10 starting pitchers whose downside should make you pause on draft day.
AMERICAN LEAGUE
José Berríos (RHP, TOR) had a really good season in 2024, at least on the surface (3.60 ERA, 1.15 WHIP in 192 IP). That said, things weren't as rosy one level lower: 20% K%, 7% BB%, 13% K-BB%, 43% GB%, 82 BPV. His very low 9.0%...
Almost!
You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!
Already a subscriber? Sign in here
More From Starting Pitchers
Ben Brown might be the best starting pitcher profit play in the game at his current market price.
Feb 28 2026 3:05am
Feb 28 2026 3:05am
Ian Seymour's intriguing command pillars make him an excellent LIMA Plan target heading into 2026.
Feb 21 2026 3:07am
Feb 21 2026 3:07am
Ben Brown's disappointing 2025 season hid a collection of intriguing skills, making him a young starter to watch this spring.
Feb 14 2026 3:05am
Feb 14 2026 3:05am
Former ace Sandy Alcantara finally looked healthy late in 2025, giving hope that he can recapture his ace-like form in 2026.
Jan 30 2026 3:05am
Jan 30 2026 3:05am
Nick Lodolo's return to health in September reinforced his rotation-anchor upside.
Jan 9 2026 3:05am
Jan 9 2026 3:05am
